Thursday, July 28, 2011

A Plan!

After spinning a few ideas around in my head and talking with my site supervisor, I believe I have come to a central question: How does the level of questioning in reading instruction (read alouds, conferencing) impact student comprehension and independent reading level?

I believe that as I raise the level of my questioning, comprehension and application of reading in the content areas will go up - then student level of questioning among themselves in reading groups will go up - which increases engagement - producing higher comprehension scores and independent reading levels. (Do you like how I used dashes to punctuate all that? I was lost in a sea of commas and semi colons, so I diverted to hyphens.)

Tool 7.1 Action Planning Template

Goal: To increase student comprehension and independent reading level by increasing the level of questioning in reading instruction (direct instruction and conferencing)

Action Step(s)

Person(s) Responsible

Timeline:

Start/End

Needed Resources

Evaluation

1. Gather initial data

Bentrup

8/20-9/30

- 10-11 EOY comprehension scores and IRL

- 11-12 BOY comprehension scores and IRL


2. Data Collection (baseline)

- student- generated questions

- teacher-generated questions

Bentrup

8/20-9/30

- Recordings of student discussion of readings

- Recordings of read alouds, conferences

- Recordings of student discussion of readings

- Recordings of read alouds, conferences

3. Examination of data

Bentrup

10/01-10/15

Recordings from Step 2

Tally/graph questions according to Bloom’s or RRR Frmwk

4. Reflection

- At what level are most of the questions (2 data sets- T/S)

- Where/How can we push those questions into a higher level?

- Goal setting

Bentrup/ Carranza

10/01-10/15

- Recordings from Step 2

- Tally/graph from Step 3

- Bloom’s/ RRR Frmwk reference list of questions/levels


5. Data Collection -implementation of ideas from Step 4

– Record student discussions, teacher instruction

Bentrup

10/15-12/20

- Recordings of student discussion of readings

- Recordings of read alouds, conferences


6. Examination of data

Bentrup

12/20-1/15

Recordings from Step 5

Tally/Graph questions according to Bloom’s or RRR Frmwk

7. Reflection

- At what level are most of the questions (2 data sets- T/S)

- Where/How can we push those questions into a higher level?

- Goal setting

Bentrup/ Carranza

12/20-1/15

- Recordings from Step 5

- Tallly/graph from Step 6

- Bloom’s/ RRR Frmwk reference list of questions/levels


8. Data Collection – implementation of ideas from Step 7 – Record student discussions and teacher instruction

Bentrup

1/15-3/15

- Recordings of student discussion of readings

- Recordings of read alouds, conferences


9. Examination of data

Bentrup

3/15-3/30

Recordings from Step 8

Tally/graph questions according to Bloom’s or RRR Frmwk

10. Reflection

- What changes, if any, have occurred?

Bentrup/ Carranza

3/30-4/30

- Recordings from Step 8

- All tally/graphs


11. End testing data

Bentrup

May 2012

- TAKS scores

- EOY IRL


12. Summary

Bentrup

May 2012

- All tally/graphs

- 11-12 BOY and EOY testing data for my class and other 4th grade classes

- Compare growth with growth in other classrooms not following the research plan

* Continue literature review throughout research process to find additional opportunities for questioning in instruction (student to student and teacher to student)

* Updated 7/31/11

Template from:

Harris, S., Edmonson, S., and Combs, J. (2010). Examining what we do to improve our schools: 8 steps to improve our schools. Eye on Education Press.

10 comments:

  1. I really like your topic for your action research plan. I think as educators we should always be looking at the level of questioning going on within our classrooms. Also your plan itself is easy to follow and makes a lot of sense. Great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Jeff. I'm glad to hear it's easy to follow. It made sense in my head, but I'm glad to hear that it makes sense out of my head as well. (Not everything does!) :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I completely agree with the thought of questioning increasing learning. Also, questioning and expaination on the part of students increases their comprehension. Your plan is very easy to follow and has made me reconsider the format that I chose for my plan. Great job!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love your topic...it is in the same realm as my research. Applying depth and complexity into math strategies to increase questioning, learning and application. Your plan is well-understood. In action 1, are you indicating boy/girl? If so, you may want to use male/female?? Just a suggestion. Great start!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Higher level questioning breeds higher level thinking - that is what we have been taught so I like your plan. You have a well thought out way of collecting and analyzing the data. Will you have your peers available to come and watch what you do?

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Terry - After the first round, I'll probably ask my collaborator to come observe. Then after that, we'll see. I work in an open concept school, so people can "see" me all the time, up and down the hallway. People passing by and dropping in on lessons is pretty commonplace. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think your plan looks great. Are you gathering your questions from others or are you creating your own?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great plan, Elizabeth! I noticed at the end of the plan you will compare the data with a class that is not using the research plan. You may want to get baseline data at the beginning of the year for that class too. You could compare the percentage of growth (BOY to EOY) for your class with the percentage of growth for theirs. You could also compare EOY scores.

    Best of luck to you! :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Elizabeth. I like the logical sequence of your action plan. I offer the following notes to hopefully help with this week's assignment:

    I would think of adding a step after step 4 soley to address the Goal setting. Making clear what "direction" the action may take. I wasn't sure who the goal setting was for: Are you setting goals for the teacher's instruction or are teachers setting goals for the students?

    I notice your have instruction listed in the goals but what form does this play in your plan. Are you going to provide teacher training in incorporating high order questioning for reading in their instruction. Will you survey current practice? If it is just your own class you could use your lesson plans as evaluation here.

    Just some thoughts- hopefully they will help?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Elizabeth,

    I really like this plan so far. I agree with David in saying that the plan is logically, and clearly presented. Questioning techniques in reading, and related effectiveness, is a great topic choice.

    Keep it up!
    Dr. Abshire

    ReplyDelete